Choosing the Right Material for Your Swimming Pool: Fiberglass vs Vinyl vs Concrete 

Choosing what type of swimming pool may not be easy with so many cool options out there. Thus, we offer some insight into the pros and cons of each material, specifically their upkeep, average time for installation, and longevity. After all, a pool is a long-term investment that you hope will bring enjoyment for your family for decades. So, take a look at each type of material and see if you can come up with the best decision that fits your wishes for an outdoor recreational area, the layout of your backyard, and of course, your budget. 

Now, some of the most popular choices for swimming pools include fiberglass, vinyl, and concrete. After looking closely at their benefits and drawbacks, you might figure out the right material for your aquatic oasis. 

Pros & Cons of Fiberglass Pools

Fiberglass pools

Fiberglass pools have their own set of pros and cons. Here are a few to consider.


The gelcoat surface is not a kind environment for algae to develop which means you use less chemicals to keep the water clean. Plus, the non-abrasive surface is easier to vacuum. However, if you happen to need a repair, you might not be able to find the same color as your pool’s surface.  

Average Installation Time

You can have a fiberglass pool installed in less time than most other choices. It only takes three to six weeks on average, considering the pool’s shell arrives already fabricated and ready to go into the excavated site. The downside to the premade shell relates to the limitations in shapes and size. In fact, you can’t have a fiberglass pool shipped to you if it’s wider than 16 feet. Plus, the initial installation cost is about as high as a concrete pool and $10,000 more than a vinyl pool.

Material longevity

A high quality pool will last about 30 years. Beyond the 20 or 30-year mark, a professional would need to perform any repairs since fiberglass is not the ideal material for a DIY project.

Pros & Cons of Vinyl Pools

Vinyl pools

Vinyl pools are quite affordable, but they have other perks and some drawbacks as well.


Like fiberglass, the vinyl has a smooth surface that won’t promote algal growth–hence less chemicals and less scrubbing. Plus, you don’t have to empty the pool when it’s time to close it. In fact, it’s best not to drain it further than halfway to protect the liner. On the other hand, you have to be ultra cautious not to allow anyone to throw any object in the pool. This is to prevent the liner from tearing. 

Average Installation Time

Having one of the shortest installation times, the vinyl pool only takes two weeks on average. On the other hand, this can vary since its size and shape are customizable. So another perk involves having more design flexibility with the vinyl pool.

Material longevity

While the initial cost for installation is one of the lowest, the liner itself doesn’t last beyond 10 years before you have to replace it. The average cost for the replacement (every 5 to 10 years) is $4500 which includes the price of filling the pool back up after the new liner is put into place.

Pros & Cons of Concrete Pools

concrete pools

Considered to be on the higher end of swimming pools, the concrete option offers benefits in design and longevity but has a few cons related to maintenance.


Unfortunately, you can’t get around the truth when it comes to maintaining a concrete pool. Due to its porous surface, you have to heavily rely on the chemicals to ward off algae and bacteria. Also, the shell raises the alkalinity of the water–which means more chemicals are needed to balance the pH level. 

Average Installation Time

Out of all the options mentioned, concrete pools take the longest to install with an average of three to six months since the base and shell are constructed on site. However, you’ll get a masterpiece of design once the pool is finished. In fact, concrete pools have the most flexibility when it comes to size and shape. 

Material longevity

Likewise, concrete pools last the longest, an average of 50 years, but the interior needs to be resurfaced every decade or so. 

Hire a Professional Contractor

Once you’ve decided on the right material for your swimming pool, you’ll need to find a skilled, licensed contractor who can create the design of your dreams. This person will have an experienced, trained team who can complete a professional installation on time and on budget. Fortunately, for the best pool contractor in New Jersey, you won’t have to look far. 


To find out more of the different types of pools, contact the pros at Custom Pool Pros. Whether you choose a fiberglass, vinyl, or concrete pool, these contractors have you covered. With over two decades of experience and numerous awards for stellar service, they can create a unique design for a pool and patio that your family will enjoy for years to come. If you have an idea for your dream aquatic space, they can turn it into reality.

    Call Now
    Get A Quote